{
  "schema_version": "h2kg-chameo-native-characterization-benchmark/v9",
  "generated_at": "2026-10-26T12:02:00+00:00",
  "source_sha256": "C3A66E75FABDAF61C60949FFC7B0E08AAD324A1F77D6137BDE60FA20797001E6",
  "case_count": 8,
  "eligible_field_count": 1635,
  "benchmark_population_audit": {
    "record_count": 8,
    "method_family_count": 7,
    "unique_profile_count": 7,
    "profile_identity_basis": "Exact equality of acquisition/instrument fields and workflow-table values after removing source coordinates and record identifiers.",
    "cases": [
      {
        "case_key": "tem",
        "sheet": "TEM",
        "record_title": "Transmission electron microscopy",
        "method_family": "TEM",
        "source_measurement_method": "TEM",
        "profile_id": "03d3b78d75728e0d",
        "profile_label_conflict": false,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": true
      },
      {
        "case_key": "sem",
        "sheet": "SEM",
        "record_title": "Scanning electron microscopy",
        "method_family": "SEM",
        "source_measurement_method": "SEM",
        "profile_id": "1868c493a494ec6e",
        "profile_label_conflict": false,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": true
      },
      {
        "case_key": "afm",
        "sheet": "AFM",
        "record_title": "Atomic force microscopy",
        "method_family": "AFM",
        "source_measurement_method": "AFM",
        "profile_id": "d52ea0804c9e925a",
        "profile_label_conflict": false,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": true
      },
      {
        "case_key": "fib_sem",
        "sheet": "FIB-SEM",
        "record_title": "FIB-SEM tomography",
        "method_family": "FIB-SEM",
        "source_measurement_method": "FIB-SEM",
        "profile_id": "11379392bd579012",
        "profile_label_conflict": false,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": false
      },
      {
        "case_key": "ic_sem",
        "sheet": "IC-SEM",
        "record_title": "Ion-cut scanning electron microscopy",
        "method_family": "IC-SEM",
        "source_measurement_method": "SEM (Ar-ion-prepared)",
        "profile_id": "fcd1365b79134916",
        "profile_label_conflict": false,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": false
      },
      {
        "case_key": "neutron_tomography",
        "sheet": "NeutronTomo",
        "record_title": "Neutron tomography",
        "method_family": "Neutron tomography",
        "source_measurement_method": "HR Neutron CT",
        "profile_id": "f899d0373f38eaa3",
        "profile_label_conflict": false,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": false
      },
      {
        "case_key": "synchrotron_radiography",
        "sheet": "SynchrotronRadio",
        "record_title": "Synchrotron X-ray radiography",
        "method_family": "Synchrotron X-ray",
        "source_measurement_method": "Synchrotron X-ray tomography",
        "profile_id": "9cfbb34e4f9f8a1e",
        "profile_label_conflict": true,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": false
      },
      {
        "case_key": "synchrotron_tomography",
        "sheet": "SynchrotronTomo",
        "record_title": "Synchrotron X-ray tomography",
        "method_family": "Synchrotron X-ray",
        "source_measurement_method": "Synchrotron X-ray tomography",
        "profile_id": "9cfbb34e4f9f8a1e",
        "profile_label_conflict": false,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": false
      }
    ],
    "profiles": [
      {
        "profile_id": "03d3b78d75728e0d",
        "case_keys": [
          "tem"
        ],
        "record_count": 1,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": true
      },
      {
        "profile_id": "11379392bd579012",
        "case_keys": [
          "fib_sem"
        ],
        "record_count": 1,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": false
      },
      {
        "profile_id": "1868c493a494ec6e",
        "case_keys": [
          "sem"
        ],
        "record_count": 1,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": true
      },
      {
        "profile_id": "9cfbb34e4f9f8a1e",
        "case_keys": [
          "synchrotron_radiography",
          "synchrotron_tomography"
        ],
        "record_count": 2,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": false
      },
      {
        "profile_id": "d52ea0804c9e925a",
        "case_keys": [
          "afm"
        ],
        "record_count": 1,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": true
      },
      {
        "profile_id": "f899d0373f38eaa3",
        "case_keys": [
          "neutron_tomography"
        ],
        "record_count": 1,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": false
      },
      {
        "profile_id": "fcd1365b79134916",
        "case_keys": [
          "ic_sem"
        ],
        "record_count": 1,
        "h2kg_dedicated_class": true,
        "chameo_dedicated_class": false
      }
    ],
    "dedicated_class_coverage": {
      "record_level": {
        "h2kg": 8,
        "chameo": 3,
        "denominator": 8
      },
      "unique_profile_level": {
        "h2kg": 7,
        "chameo": 3,
        "denominator": 7
      }
    },
    "measurement_settings": {
      "distinct_identities": 131,
      "parsed_recognized_unit_rows": 107,
      "excluded_from_parsed_unit_assessment": 24,
      "exclusion_reason_counts": {
        "not_applicable": 2,
        "not_specified": 5,
        "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair": 16,
        "unconfirmed": 1
      },
      "exclusions": [
        {
          "case_key": "afm",
          "setting": "DataAdquisitionRate parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "1024",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "fib_sem",
          "setting": "MeasuredArea / um2 parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "20",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "fib_sem",
          "setting": "PlaneSpacing parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "10",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "fib_sem",
          "setting": "StageTilt parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "54",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "ic_sem",
          "setting": "MeasuredArea / um2 parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "20",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "ic_sem",
          "setting": "PlaneSpacing parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "10",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "neutron_tomography",
          "setting": "MaximalWavelenght parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "44593",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "neutron_tomography",
          "setting": "NeutronFlux parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "2.7 x 10^6",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "sem",
          "setting": "DataAdquisitionRate parameter record",
          "source_status": "not_specified",
          "raw_value": "-",
          "exclusion_reason": "not_specified"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "sem",
          "setting": "Humidity parameter record",
          "source_status": "not_applicable",
          "raw_value": "Not applicable",
          "exclusion_reason": "not_applicable"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "sem",
          "setting": "Pressure parameter record",
          "source_status": "not_specified",
          "raw_value": "Not specified",
          "exclusion_reason": "not_specified"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_radiography",
          "setting": "Binning parameter record",
          "source_status": "not_specified",
          "raw_value": "None",
          "exclusion_reason": "not_specified"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_radiography",
          "setting": "EnergyResolution parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "10^-2",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_radiography",
          "setting": "FieldOfViewX parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "26.68",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_radiography",
          "setting": "FieldOfViewY parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "8",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_radiography",
          "setting": "RotationDegree parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "180",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_tomography",
          "setting": "Binning parameter record",
          "source_status": "not_specified",
          "raw_value": "None",
          "exclusion_reason": "not_specified"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_tomography",
          "setting": "EnergyResolution parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "10^-2",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_tomography",
          "setting": "FieldOfViewX parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "26.68",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_tomography",
          "setting": "FieldOfViewY parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "8",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_tomography",
          "setting": "RotationDegree parameter record",
          "source_status": "reported",
          "raw_value": "180",
          "exclusion_reason": "reported_without_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "tem",
          "setting": "DataAdquisitionRate parameter record",
          "source_status": "not_specified",
          "raw_value": "-",
          "exclusion_reason": "not_specified"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "tem",
          "setting": "Humidity parameter record",
          "source_status": "not_applicable",
          "raw_value": "Not applicable",
          "exclusion_reason": "not_applicable"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "tem",
          "setting": "WorkingDistance parameter record",
          "source_status": "unconfirmed",
          "raw_value": "To be confirmed",
          "exclusion_reason": "unconfirmed"
        }
      ]
    },
    "reported_results": {
      "distinct_records": 24,
      "parsed_recognized_unit_rows": 13,
      "excluded_from_parsed_unit_assessment": 11,
      "exclusions": [
        {
          "case_key": "sem",
          "property": "Support-needle length",
          "raw_value": "Up to ~110 µm",
          "exclusion_reason": "no_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "fib_sem",
          "property": "Volume fraction",
          "raw_value": "80 nm",
          "exclusion_reason": "no_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "fib_sem",
          "property": "Porosity",
          "raw_value": "10 pu",
          "exclusion_reason": "no_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "fib_sem",
          "property": "Direction",
          "raw_value": "6 °",
          "exclusion_reason": "no_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "fib_sem",
          "property": "Network relation",
          "raw_value": "7 pu",
          "exclusion_reason": "no_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "fib_sem",
          "property": "Constrictivity",
          "raw_value": "8 pu",
          "exclusion_reason": "no_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "fib_sem",
          "property": "Mean geodesic torutosity",
          "raw_value": "9 pu",
          "exclusion_reason": "no_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "ic_sem",
          "property": "Porosity",
          "raw_value": "6 pu",
          "exclusion_reason": "no_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "neutron_tomography",
          "property": "AverageBaryCenter",
          "raw_value": "5",
          "exclusion_reason": "no_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_radiography",
          "property": "carbonfelt/electrolyte/air ratio",
          "raw_value": "03:02:01",
          "exclusion_reason": "no_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_tomography",
          "property": "carbonfelt/electrolyte/air ratio",
          "raw_value": "03:02:01",
          "exclusion_reason": "no_parseable_numeric_recognized_unit_pair"
        }
      ],
      "property_unit_compatibility_counts": {
        "no_detected_property_unit_conflict": 11,
        "semantic_conflict": 2
      },
      "property_unit_compatibility": [
        {
          "case_key": "afm",
          "property": "Average size",
          "value": "110",
          "unit": "http://qudt.org/vocab/unit/MicroM",
          "compatibility_status": "no_detected_property_unit_conflict",
          "verification_status": "not_independently_verified",
          "rationale": "The explicit property/unit rule found no dimensional conflict; this does not verify the reported value scientifically."
        },
        {
          "case_key": "ic_sem",
          "property": "GDL thickness",
          "value": "160",
          "unit": "http://qudt.org/vocab/unit/NanoM",
          "compatibility_status": "no_detected_property_unit_conflict",
          "verification_status": "not_independently_verified",
          "rationale": "The explicit property/unit rule found no dimensional conflict; this does not verify the reported value scientifically."
        },
        {
          "case_key": "ic_sem",
          "property": "MEA thickness",
          "value": "80",
          "unit": "http://qudt.org/vocab/unit/NanoM",
          "compatibility_status": "no_detected_property_unit_conflict",
          "verification_status": "not_independently_verified",
          "rationale": "The explicit property/unit rule found no dimensional conflict; this does not verify the reported value scientifically."
        },
        {
          "case_key": "neutron_tomography",
          "property": "AverageArea",
          "value": "45",
          "unit": "http://qudt.org/vocab/unit/CentiM2",
          "compatibility_status": "no_detected_property_unit_conflict",
          "verification_status": "not_independently_verified",
          "rationale": "The explicit property/unit rule found no dimensional conflict; this does not verify the reported value scientifically."
        },
        {
          "case_key": "neutron_tomography",
          "property": "AverageNumber",
          "value": "45",
          "unit": "http://qudt.org/vocab/unit/UNITLESS",
          "compatibility_status": "no_detected_property_unit_conflict",
          "verification_status": "not_independently_verified",
          "rationale": "The explicit property/unit rule found no dimensional conflict; this does not verify the reported value scientifically."
        },
        {
          "case_key": "neutron_tomography",
          "property": "Tortuosity Factor",
          "value": "1.5",
          "unit": "http://qudt.org/vocab/unit/UNITLESS",
          "compatibility_status": "no_detected_property_unit_conflict",
          "verification_status": "not_independently_verified",
          "rationale": "The explicit property/unit rule found no dimensional conflict; this does not verify the reported value scientifically."
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_radiography",
          "property": "Decay factor",
          "value": "51",
          "unit": "http://qudt.org/vocab/unit/MilliSEC",
          "compatibility_status": "no_detected_property_unit_conflict",
          "verification_status": "not_independently_verified",
          "rationale": "The explicit property/unit rule found no dimensional conflict; this does not verify the reported value scientifically."
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_radiography",
          "property": "Electrolyte saturation",
          "value": "47",
          "unit": "http://qudt.org/vocab/unit/MOL-PER-L",
          "compatibility_status": "semantic_conflict",
          "verification_status": "not_independently_verified",
          "rationale": "The source label denotes saturation, ordinarily a dimensionless fraction, whereas mol/L denotes amount-of-substance concentration. The source value remains queryable but is not treated as a scientifically compatible quantity."
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_radiography",
          "property": "Real distance in beam path",
          "value": "99",
          "unit": "http://qudt.org/vocab/unit/CentiM",
          "compatibility_status": "no_detected_property_unit_conflict",
          "verification_status": "not_independently_verified",
          "rationale": "The explicit property/unit rule found no dimensional conflict; this does not verify the reported value scientifically."
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_tomography",
          "property": "Decay factor",
          "value": "51",
          "unit": "http://qudt.org/vocab/unit/MilliSEC",
          "compatibility_status": "no_detected_property_unit_conflict",
          "verification_status": "not_independently_verified",
          "rationale": "The explicit property/unit rule found no dimensional conflict; this does not verify the reported value scientifically."
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_tomography",
          "property": "Electrolyte saturation",
          "value": "47",
          "unit": "http://qudt.org/vocab/unit/MOL-PER-L",
          "compatibility_status": "semantic_conflict",
          "verification_status": "not_independently_verified",
          "rationale": "The source label denotes saturation, ordinarily a dimensionless fraction, whereas mol/L denotes amount-of-substance concentration. The source value remains queryable but is not treated as a scientifically compatible quantity."
        },
        {
          "case_key": "synchrotron_tomography",
          "property": "Real distance in beam path",
          "value": "99",
          "unit": "http://qudt.org/vocab/unit/CentiM",
          "compatibility_status": "no_detected_property_unit_conflict",
          "verification_status": "not_independently_verified",
          "rationale": "The explicit property/unit rule found no dimensional conflict; this does not verify the reported value scientifically."
        },
        {
          "case_key": "tem",
          "property": "Average size",
          "value": "5",
          "unit": "http://qudt.org/vocab/unit/NanoM",
          "compatibility_status": "no_detected_property_unit_conflict",
          "verification_status": "not_independently_verified",
          "rationale": "The explicit property/unit rule found no dimensional conflict; this does not verify the reported value scientifically."
        }
      ],
      "compatibility_scope": "Rule-based property/unit compatibility screening is separate from numeric parsing and unit recognition; it is not independent verification of the reported measurements."
    }
  },
  "benchmark_contract": {
    "schema_version": "h2kg-chameo-fair-characterization-contract/v5",
    "source_manifest_sha256": "C3A66E75FABDAF61C60949FFC7B0E08AAD324A1F77D6137BDE60FA20797001E6",
    "requirement_count": 13,
    "selection_strata": {
      "analysis_lineage": 1,
      "data_processing": 1,
      "measurement_context": 1,
      "measurement_settings": 2,
      "methodology_description": 1,
      "result_provenance": 1,
      "result_semantics": 2,
      "selected_profile_vocabulary": 1,
      "software_traceability": 1,
      "specimen_preparation": 1,
      "workflow_structure": 1
    },
    "contract_sha256": "1DF11D480C1CC8AFAE618B5C7299C20E4EA0DB9FCD6B6188413B32CC373A352E",
    "selection_protocol": [
      "Enumerate the specimen-to-result information lifecycle present in the sanitized workbook.",
      "Score each scientific relation or value pattern once over the full eight-record population; do not repeat it as global and per-record questions.",
      "Derive every requirement from information present in the application lifecycle and label it by scientific function, never by ontology origin.",
      "Include selected-profile native vocabulary coverage as an explicit scored requirement rather than an unscored post hoc argument.",
      "Generate expected rows from the manifest before executing ontology-specific SPARQL or native-pattern assessment.",
      "Compare deduplicated result sets after normalizing numeric lexical forms only; preserve all other selected values exactly.",
      "Treat numeric parsing and recognized-unit mapping separately from rule-based property/unit compatibility screening.",
      "Disallow local semantic bridge predicates and report shared standards and declared imports separately.",
      "Credit generic native patterns as successful while reporting their semantic specificity separately from specialised native patterns."
    ],
    "inference_scope": "The resulting requirement-satisfaction decisions apply only to these thirteen frozen retrieval, native-pattern, and vocabulary-coverage assessments over eight source records representing seven unique profiles.",
    "conclusion_rules": [
      {
        "id": "r1_chameo_broad_methodology",
        "criterion": "CHAMEO is exact for measurement context, setting identity, preparation, processing, software, analysis lineage, result generation, workflow/task grouping, and technique/occurrence separation."
      },
      {
        "id": "r2_chameo_unique_methodology_patterns",
        "criterion": "CHAMEO supplies specialised workflow/task and technique-description patterns; H2KG can group activities generically but lacks a separate technique-description pattern."
      },
      {
        "id": "r3_h2kg_valued_settings",
        "criterion": "H2KG is exact, while no declared ancestry-compatible path from a CHAMEO measurement-parameter record to a distinct valued scientific characteristic was identified under the benchmark's permitted native-encoding rules."
      },
      {
        "id": "r4_h2kg_individual_results",
        "criterion": "H2KG is exact for individual result/property/bearer associations and parsed numeric values with recognized units, while CHAMEO is not exact for the individual association contract."
      },
      {
        "id": "r5_h2kg_method_specificity",
        "criterion": "H2KG has greater native class coverage at the predefined profile granularity than CHAMEO for the selected source records."
      }
    ],
    "requirements": [
      {
        "id": "b01_measurement_context",
        "question": "Which specimen, instrument, and raw dataset belong to each measurement?",
        "selection_stratum": "measurement_context",
        "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
        "source_basis": "Case identity, specimen field, method family, and raw-data output in the sanitized manifest.",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "measurementLabel",
          "specimenLabel",
          "instrumentLabel",
          "rawDatasetLabel"
        ]
      },
      {
        "id": "b02_measurement_setting_identity",
        "question": "Which named measurement settings are associated with each measurement?",
        "selection_stratum": "measurement_settings",
        "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
        "source_basis": "All characteristic and instrument fields classified as measurement settings in the sanitized manifest.",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "parameterLabel"
        ]
      },
      {
        "id": "b03_valued_measurement_setting",
        "question": "Which measurement-setting record denotes which scientific characteristic, with what parsed numeric value and recognized unit?",
        "selection_stratum": "measurement_settings",
        "assessment_type": "query_retrieval_and_native_pattern_assessment",
        "source_basis": "Reported measurement settings with a distinct scientific characteristic, a parseable numeric value, and a recognized unit in the sanitized manifest.",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "parameterLabel",
          "propertyLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ]
      },
      {
        "id": "b04_preparation_input_output",
        "question": "Which material input and output are connected by each specimen-preparation step?",
        "selection_stratum": "specimen_preparation",
        "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
        "source_basis": "Synthesis and specimen-preparation rows in all eight source records.",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "processLabel",
          "inputMaterialLabel",
          "outputMaterialLabel"
        ]
      },
      {
        "id": "b05_processing_input_output",
        "question": "Which input and output datasets are connected by each preprocessing step?",
        "selection_stratum": "data_processing",
        "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
        "source_basis": "Preprocessing rows in all eight source records.",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "processLabel",
          "inputDataLabel",
          "outputDataLabel"
        ]
      },
      {
        "id": "b06_software_association",
        "question": "Which software is associated with each preparation, processing, or analysis step?",
        "selection_stratum": "software_traceability",
        "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
        "source_basis": "Software fields in all workflow-table sections.",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "processLabel",
          "softwareLabel"
        ]
      },
      {
        "id": "b07_analysis_lineage",
        "question": "Which input dataset, analysis step, software, and result form each analysis lineage?",
        "selection_stratum": "analysis_lineage",
        "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
        "source_basis": "Analysis rows and software fields in all eight source records.",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "analysisLabel",
          "inputDataLabel",
          "resultLabel",
          "softwareLabel"
        ]
      },
      {
        "id": "b08_individual_result_property_bearer",
        "question": "Which property and specimen are linked to each individual reported result?",
        "selection_stratum": "result_semantics",
        "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
        "source_basis": "Every analysis target and the case specimen in the sanitized manifest.",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "resultLabel",
          "propertyLabel",
          "bearerLabel"
        ]
      },
      {
        "id": "b09_parsed_result_value_and_unit",
        "question": "Which reported result properties have a parsed numeric value and recognized unit?",
        "selection_stratum": "result_semantics",
        "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
        "source_basis": "Analysis outputs with a parseable numeric value and recognized unit in the sanitized manifest; property-unit compatibility is audited separately.",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "propertyLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ]
      },
      {
        "id": "b10_result_generation",
        "question": "Which analysis step generated each individual result?",
        "selection_stratum": "result_provenance",
        "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
        "source_basis": "Analysis-step and target pairs in all eight source records.",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "analysisLabel",
          "resultLabel"
        ]
      },
      {
        "id": "b11_workflow_task_grouping",
        "question": "Which named workflow groups the measurement and processing tasks for each case?",
        "selection_stratum": "workflow_structure",
        "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
        "source_basis": "Each case is one bounded characterization workflow containing one measurement and its distinct source-defined steps.",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "workflowLabel",
          "taskCount"
        ]
      },
      {
        "id": "b12_technique_occurrence_separation",
        "question": "Which technique description is explicitly distinguished from, and linked to, each measurement occurrence?",
        "selection_stratum": "methodology_description",
        "assessment_type": "query_retrieval_and_native_pattern_assessment",
        "source_basis": "The method-family descriptor and measurement occurrence recorded for every case.",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "techniqueLabel",
          "measurementLabel"
        ]
      },
      {
        "id": "b13_case_method_specificity",
        "question": "Does each source record resolve to a dedicated native ontology class at the specificity of its selected characterization profile?",
        "selection_stratum": "selected_profile_vocabulary",
        "assessment_type": "native_vocabulary_coverage",
        "source_basis": "The curated characterization-profile identity recorded for each of the eight workbook records.",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "methodLabel"
        ]
      }
    ]
  },
  "balanced_benchmark": {
    "requirement_count": 13,
    "selection_strata": {
      "analysis_lineage": 1,
      "data_processing": 1,
      "measurement_context": 1,
      "measurement_settings": 2,
      "methodology_description": 1,
      "result_provenance": 1,
      "result_semantics": 2,
      "selected_profile_vocabulary": 1,
      "software_traceability": 1,
      "specimen_preparation": 1,
      "workflow_structure": 1
    },
    "assessment_type_counts": {
      "native_vocabulary_coverage": 1,
      "query_based_retrieval": 10,
      "query_retrieval_and_native_pattern_assessment": 2
    },
    "aggregation_policy": "Each requirement is counted once. Numeric lexical forms are normalized and rows are deduplicated before set comparison; row counts are reported per requirement and are not pooled into a weighted quality score.",
    "h2kg": {
      "exact_requirements": 12,
      "partial_requirements": 0,
      "native_pattern_not_supported_requirements": 1,
      "no_match_requirements": 0
    },
    "chameo": {
      "exact_requirements": 10,
      "partial_requirements": 2,
      "native_pattern_not_supported_requirements": 1,
      "no_match_requirements": 0
    }
  },
  "balanced_requirement_matrix": [
    {
      "requirement_id": "b01_measurement_context",
      "plain_language_question": "Which specimen, instrument, and raw dataset belong to each measurement?",
      "selection_stratum": "measurement_context",
      "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
      "expected_rows": 8,
      "variables": "caseKey;measurementLabel;specimenLabel;instrumentLabel;rawDatasetLabel",
      "h2kg_status": "exact",
      "h2kg_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "h2kg_query_executed": true,
      "h2kg_representation_tier": "direct_native",
      "h2kg_matched": 8,
      "h2kg_missing": 0,
      "h2kg_unexpected": 0,
      "h2kg_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_rationale": "Direct subject, instrument, and output-data relations.",
      "h2kg_triple_patterns": 8,
      "h2kg_joins": 0,
      "h2kg_optional_blocks": 0,
      "h2kg_property_paths": 0,
      "h2kg_lines": 10,
      "chameo_status": "exact",
      "chameo_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "chameo_query_executed": true,
      "chameo_representation_tier": "direct_native",
      "chameo_matched": 8,
      "chameo_missing": 0,
      "chameo_unexpected": 0,
      "chameo_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_rationale": "Direct subject, instrument, and output-data relations.",
      "chameo_triple_patterns": 9,
      "chameo_joins": 0,
      "chameo_optional_blocks": 0,
      "chameo_property_paths": 0,
      "chameo_lines": 11
    },
    {
      "requirement_id": "b02_measurement_setting_identity",
      "plain_language_question": "Which named measurement settings are associated with each measurement?",
      "selection_stratum": "measurement_settings",
      "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
      "expected_rows": 131,
      "variables": "caseKey;parameterLabel",
      "h2kg_status": "exact",
      "h2kg_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "h2kg_query_executed": true,
      "h2kg_representation_tier": "direct_native",
      "h2kg_matched": 131,
      "h2kg_missing": 0,
      "h2kg_unexpected": 0,
      "h2kg_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_rationale": "Direct measurement-to-parameter relation.",
      "h2kg_triple_patterns": 3,
      "h2kg_joins": 0,
      "h2kg_optional_blocks": 0,
      "h2kg_property_paths": 0,
      "h2kg_lines": 10,
      "chameo_status": "exact",
      "chameo_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "chameo_query_executed": true,
      "chameo_representation_tier": "direct_native",
      "chameo_matched": 131,
      "chameo_missing": 0,
      "chameo_unexpected": 0,
      "chameo_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_rationale": "Direct measurement-to-parameter relation.",
      "chameo_triple_patterns": 3,
      "chameo_joins": 0,
      "chameo_optional_blocks": 0,
      "chameo_property_paths": 0,
      "chameo_lines": 11
    },
    {
      "requirement_id": "b03_valued_measurement_setting",
      "plain_language_question": "Which measurement-setting record denotes which scientific characteristic, with what parsed numeric value and recognized unit?",
      "selection_stratum": "measurement_settings",
      "assessment_type": "query_retrieval_and_native_pattern_assessment",
      "expected_rows": 107,
      "variables": "caseKey;parameterLabel;propertyLabel;value;unit",
      "h2kg_status": "exact",
      "h2kg_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "h2kg_query_executed": true,
      "h2kg_representation_tier": "direct_native_plus_shared_standard",
      "h2kg_matched": 107,
      "h2kg_missing": 0,
      "h2kg_unexpected": 0,
      "h2kg_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_rationale": "H2KG binds a parameter record to a property occurrence; QUDT supplies value and unit terms.",
      "h2kg_triple_patterns": 8,
      "h2kg_joins": 0,
      "h2kg_optional_blocks": 0,
      "h2kg_property_paths": 0,
      "h2kg_lines": 15,
      "chameo_status": "not_supported_under_benchmark_mapping_rules",
      "chameo_assessment_mode": "native_pattern_assessment",
      "chameo_query_executed": false,
      "chameo_representation_tier": "native_pattern_not_identified_under_mapping_rules",
      "chameo_matched": 0,
      "chameo_missing": 107,
      "chameo_unexpected": 0,
      "chameo_precision_percent": 0.0,
      "chameo_recall_percent": 0.0,
      "chameo_rationale": "Under the benchmark's permitted native encoding, no declared ancestry-compatible relation was identified from CHAMEO MeasurementParameter to a distinct valued scientific characteristic. This bounded finding does not establish that every possible CHAMEO/EMMO representation is prohibited.",
      "chameo_triple_patterns": 0,
      "chameo_joins": 0,
      "chameo_optional_blocks": 0,
      "chameo_property_paths": 0,
      "chameo_lines": 0
    },
    {
      "requirement_id": "b04_preparation_input_output",
      "plain_language_question": "Which material input and output are connected by each specimen-preparation step?",
      "selection_stratum": "specimen_preparation",
      "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
      "expected_rows": 83,
      "variables": "caseKey;processLabel;inputMaterialLabel;outputMaterialLabel",
      "h2kg_status": "exact",
      "h2kg_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "h2kg_query_executed": true,
      "h2kg_representation_tier": "direct_native",
      "h2kg_matched": 83,
      "h2kg_missing": 0,
      "h2kg_unexpected": 0,
      "h2kg_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_rationale": "Native preparation semantics; CHAMEO uses its declared EMMO output relation.",
      "h2kg_triple_patterns": 6,
      "h2kg_joins": 0,
      "h2kg_optional_blocks": 0,
      "h2kg_property_paths": 0,
      "h2kg_lines": 13,
      "chameo_status": "exact",
      "chameo_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "chameo_query_executed": true,
      "chameo_representation_tier": "direct_native_plus_declared_import",
      "chameo_matched": 83,
      "chameo_missing": 0,
      "chameo_unexpected": 0,
      "chameo_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_rationale": "Native preparation semantics; CHAMEO uses its declared EMMO output relation.",
      "chameo_triple_patterns": 6,
      "chameo_joins": 0,
      "chameo_optional_blocks": 0,
      "chameo_property_paths": 0,
      "chameo_lines": 14
    },
    {
      "requirement_id": "b05_processing_input_output",
      "plain_language_question": "Which input and output datasets are connected by each preprocessing step?",
      "selection_stratum": "data_processing",
      "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
      "expected_rows": 29,
      "variables": "caseKey;processLabel;inputDataLabel;outputDataLabel",
      "h2kg_status": "exact",
      "h2kg_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "h2kg_query_executed": true,
      "h2kg_representation_tier": "direct_native",
      "h2kg_matched": 29,
      "h2kg_missing": 0,
      "h2kg_unexpected": 0,
      "h2kg_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_rationale": "Direct processing input and output relations.",
      "h2kg_triple_patterns": 6,
      "h2kg_joins": 0,
      "h2kg_optional_blocks": 0,
      "h2kg_property_paths": 0,
      "h2kg_lines": 8,
      "chameo_status": "exact",
      "chameo_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "chameo_query_executed": true,
      "chameo_representation_tier": "direct_native",
      "chameo_matched": 29,
      "chameo_missing": 0,
      "chameo_unexpected": 0,
      "chameo_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_rationale": "Direct processing input and output relations.",
      "chameo_triple_patterns": 6,
      "chameo_joins": 0,
      "chameo_optional_blocks": 0,
      "chameo_property_paths": 0,
      "chameo_lines": 9
    },
    {
      "requirement_id": "b06_software_association",
      "plain_language_question": "Which software is associated with each preparation, processing, or analysis step?",
      "selection_stratum": "software_traceability",
      "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
      "expected_rows": 31,
      "variables": "caseKey;processLabel;softwareLabel",
      "h2kg_status": "exact",
      "h2kg_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "h2kg_query_executed": true,
      "h2kg_representation_tier": "direct_native",
      "h2kg_matched": 31,
      "h2kg_missing": 0,
      "h2kg_unexpected": 0,
      "h2kg_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_rationale": "Direct process-to-software relation.",
      "h2kg_triple_patterns": 3,
      "h2kg_joins": 0,
      "h2kg_optional_blocks": 0,
      "h2kg_property_paths": 0,
      "h2kg_lines": 8,
      "chameo_status": "exact",
      "chameo_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "chameo_query_executed": true,
      "chameo_representation_tier": "direct_native",
      "chameo_matched": 31,
      "chameo_missing": 0,
      "chameo_unexpected": 0,
      "chameo_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_rationale": "Direct process-to-software relation.",
      "chameo_triple_patterns": 3,
      "chameo_joins": 0,
      "chameo_optional_blocks": 0,
      "chameo_property_paths": 0,
      "chameo_lines": 9
    },
    {
      "requirement_id": "b07_analysis_lineage",
      "plain_language_question": "Which input dataset, analysis step, software, and result form each analysis lineage?",
      "selection_stratum": "analysis_lineage",
      "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
      "expected_rows": 27,
      "variables": "caseKey;analysisLabel;inputDataLabel;resultLabel;softwareLabel",
      "h2kg_status": "exact",
      "h2kg_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "h2kg_query_executed": true,
      "h2kg_representation_tier": "direct_native",
      "h2kg_matched": 27,
      "h2kg_missing": 0,
      "h2kg_unexpected": 0,
      "h2kg_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_rationale": "Direct analysis input, output, and software relations.",
      "h2kg_triple_patterns": 8,
      "h2kg_joins": 0,
      "h2kg_optional_blocks": 1,
      "h2kg_property_paths": 0,
      "h2kg_lines": 10,
      "chameo_status": "exact",
      "chameo_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "chameo_query_executed": true,
      "chameo_representation_tier": "direct_native",
      "chameo_matched": 27,
      "chameo_missing": 0,
      "chameo_unexpected": 0,
      "chameo_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_rationale": "Direct analysis input, output, and software relations.",
      "chameo_triple_patterns": 9,
      "chameo_joins": 0,
      "chameo_optional_blocks": 1,
      "chameo_property_paths": 0,
      "chameo_lines": 11
    },
    {
      "requirement_id": "b08_individual_result_property_bearer",
      "plain_language_question": "Which property and specimen are linked to each individual reported result?",
      "selection_stratum": "result_semantics",
      "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
      "expected_rows": 24,
      "variables": "caseKey;resultLabel;propertyLabel;bearerLabel",
      "h2kg_status": "exact",
      "h2kg_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "h2kg_query_executed": true,
      "h2kg_representation_tier": "direct_native",
      "h2kg_matched": 24,
      "h2kg_missing": 0,
      "h2kg_unexpected": 0,
      "h2kg_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_rationale": "Each result record directly identifies one property occurrence and its bearer.",
      "h2kg_triple_patterns": 6,
      "h2kg_joins": 0,
      "h2kg_optional_blocks": 0,
      "h2kg_property_paths": 0,
      "h2kg_lines": 11,
      "chameo_status": "partial",
      "chameo_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "chameo_query_executed": true,
      "chameo_representation_tier": "declared_import_process_level_pattern",
      "chameo_matched": 24,
      "chameo_missing": 0,
      "chameo_unexpected": 2,
      "chameo_precision_percent": 92.31,
      "chameo_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_rationale": "The imported process-level determination pattern can become ambiguous when one analysis has several outputs and properties.",
      "chameo_triple_patterns": 10,
      "chameo_joins": 0,
      "chameo_optional_blocks": 0,
      "chameo_property_paths": 0,
      "chameo_lines": 15
    },
    {
      "requirement_id": "b09_parsed_result_value_and_unit",
      "plain_language_question": "Which reported result properties have a parsed numeric value and recognized unit?",
      "selection_stratum": "result_semantics",
      "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
      "expected_rows": 13,
      "variables": "caseKey;propertyLabel;value;unit",
      "h2kg_status": "exact",
      "h2kg_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "h2kg_query_executed": true,
      "h2kg_representation_tier": "direct_native_plus_shared_standard",
      "h2kg_matched": 13,
      "h2kg_missing": 0,
      "h2kg_unexpected": 0,
      "h2kg_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_rationale": "The ontology-specific result/property path is combined with shared QUDT value and unit terms.",
      "h2kg_triple_patterns": 56,
      "h2kg_joins": 0,
      "h2kg_optional_blocks": 0,
      "h2kg_property_paths": 0,
      "h2kg_lines": 45,
      "chameo_status": "exact",
      "chameo_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "chameo_query_executed": true,
      "chameo_representation_tier": "declared_import_plus_shared_standard",
      "chameo_matched": 13,
      "chameo_missing": 0,
      "chameo_unexpected": 0,
      "chameo_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_rationale": "The ontology-specific result/property path is combined with shared QUDT value and unit terms.",
      "chameo_triple_patterns": 88,
      "chameo_joins": 0,
      "chameo_optional_blocks": 0,
      "chameo_property_paths": 0,
      "chameo_lines": 78
    },
    {
      "requirement_id": "b10_result_generation",
      "plain_language_question": "Which analysis step generated each individual result?",
      "selection_stratum": "result_provenance",
      "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
      "expected_rows": 24,
      "variables": "caseKey;analysisLabel;resultLabel",
      "h2kg_status": "exact",
      "h2kg_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "h2kg_query_executed": true,
      "h2kg_representation_tier": "shared_standard",
      "h2kg_matched": 24,
      "h2kg_missing": 0,
      "h2kg_unexpected": 0,
      "h2kg_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_rationale": "Both graphs use the same PROV-O generation relation.",
      "h2kg_triple_patterns": 4,
      "h2kg_joins": 0,
      "h2kg_optional_blocks": 0,
      "h2kg_property_paths": 0,
      "h2kg_lines": 13,
      "chameo_status": "exact",
      "chameo_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "chameo_query_executed": true,
      "chameo_representation_tier": "shared_standard",
      "chameo_matched": 24,
      "chameo_missing": 0,
      "chameo_unexpected": 0,
      "chameo_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_rationale": "Both graphs use the same PROV-O generation relation.",
      "chameo_triple_patterns": 4,
      "chameo_joins": 0,
      "chameo_optional_blocks": 0,
      "chameo_property_paths": 0,
      "chameo_lines": 14
    },
    {
      "requirement_id": "b11_workflow_task_grouping",
      "plain_language_question": "Which named workflow groups the measurement and processing tasks for each case?",
      "selection_stratum": "workflow_structure",
      "assessment_type": "query_based_retrieval",
      "expected_rows": 8,
      "variables": "caseKey;workflowLabel;taskCount",
      "h2kg_status": "exact",
      "h2kg_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "h2kg_query_executed": true,
      "h2kg_representation_tier": "generic_direct_native",
      "h2kg_matched": 8,
      "h2kg_missing": 0,
      "h2kg_unexpected": 0,
      "h2kg_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_rationale": "H2KG's generic Process/hasPart pattern groups the source-defined activities.",
      "h2kg_triple_patterns": 3,
      "h2kg_joins": 0,
      "h2kg_optional_blocks": 0,
      "h2kg_property_paths": 0,
      "h2kg_lines": 12,
      "chameo_status": "exact",
      "chameo_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "chameo_query_executed": true,
      "chameo_representation_tier": "direct_native",
      "chameo_matched": 8,
      "chameo_missing": 0,
      "chameo_unexpected": 0,
      "chameo_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_rationale": "CHAMEO explicitly groups CharacterisationTask descriptions in a CharacterisationWorkflow.",
      "chameo_triple_patterns": 3,
      "chameo_joins": 0,
      "chameo_optional_blocks": 0,
      "chameo_property_paths": 0,
      "chameo_lines": 13
    },
    {
      "requirement_id": "b12_technique_occurrence_separation",
      "plain_language_question": "Which technique description is explicitly distinguished from, and linked to, each measurement occurrence?",
      "selection_stratum": "methodology_description",
      "assessment_type": "query_retrieval_and_native_pattern_assessment",
      "expected_rows": 8,
      "variables": "caseKey;techniqueLabel;measurementLabel",
      "h2kg_status": "not_supported_under_benchmark_mapping_rules",
      "h2kg_assessment_mode": "native_pattern_assessment",
      "h2kg_query_executed": false,
      "h2kg_representation_tier": "native_pattern_not_identified_under_mapping_rules",
      "h2kg_matched": 0,
      "h2kg_missing": 8,
      "h2kg_unexpected": 0,
      "h2kg_precision_percent": 0.0,
      "h2kg_recall_percent": 0.0,
      "h2kg_rationale": "Under the benchmark's permitted native encoding, H2KG identifies the method by typing the measurement occurrence; no separate technique-description resource and linking relation was identified in the pinned core. This is not a general impossibility claim.",
      "h2kg_triple_patterns": 0,
      "h2kg_joins": 0,
      "h2kg_optional_blocks": 0,
      "h2kg_property_paths": 0,
      "h2kg_lines": 0,
      "chameo_status": "exact",
      "chameo_assessment_mode": "sparql_query",
      "chameo_query_executed": true,
      "chameo_representation_tier": "direct_native_plus_declared_import",
      "chameo_matched": 8,
      "chameo_missing": 0,
      "chameo_unexpected": 0,
      "chameo_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_rationale": "CHAMEO supplies the technique descriptor and its declared EMMO import supplies the description-to-occurrence relation.",
      "chameo_triple_patterns": 5,
      "chameo_joins": 0,
      "chameo_optional_blocks": 0,
      "chameo_property_paths": 0,
      "chameo_lines": 15
    },
    {
      "requirement_id": "b13_case_method_specificity",
      "plain_language_question": "Does each source record resolve to a dedicated native ontology class at the specificity of its selected characterization profile?",
      "selection_stratum": "selected_profile_vocabulary",
      "assessment_type": "native_vocabulary_coverage",
      "expected_rows": 8,
      "variables": "caseKey;methodLabel",
      "h2kg_status": "exact",
      "h2kg_assessment_mode": "native_vocabulary_coverage",
      "h2kg_query_executed": false,
      "h2kg_representation_tier": "native_class_coverage_audit",
      "h2kg_matched": 8,
      "h2kg_missing": 0,
      "h2kg_unexpected": 0,
      "h2kg_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "h2kg_rationale": "Evaluated against the ontology class inventory and source method identity rather than an ABox query.",
      "h2kg_triple_patterns": 0,
      "h2kg_joins": 0,
      "h2kg_optional_blocks": 0,
      "h2kg_property_paths": 0,
      "h2kg_lines": 0,
      "chameo_status": "partial",
      "chameo_assessment_mode": "native_vocabulary_coverage",
      "chameo_query_executed": false,
      "chameo_representation_tier": "native_class_coverage_audit",
      "chameo_matched": 3,
      "chameo_missing": 5,
      "chameo_unexpected": 0,
      "chameo_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "chameo_recall_percent": 37.5,
      "chameo_rationale": "Evaluated against the ontology class inventory and source method identity rather than an ABox query.",
      "chameo_triple_patterns": 0,
      "chameo_joins": 0,
      "chameo_optional_blocks": 0,
      "chameo_property_paths": 0,
      "chameo_lines": 0
    }
  ],
  "balanced_conclusion": {
    "rules": {
      "chameo_broad_characterization_methodology": true,
      "chameo_specialized_methodology_patterns": true,
      "h2kg_direct_valued_parameter_pattern": true,
      "h2kg_individual_result_pattern": true,
      "h2kg_greater_case_method_specificity": true,
      "h2kg_specific_method_count": 8,
      "chameo_specific_method_count": 3,
      "complementarity_conclusion_supported": true
    },
    "supported": true,
    "statement": "For the selected characterization profiles, the benchmark supports a scoped complementarity conclusion: CHAMEO provides explicit characterization-methodology structures, while H₂KG provides greater native class coverage at the predefined profile granularity together with direct valued-parameter and individually provenance-linked result patterns.",
    "scope": "The 12/13 and 10/13 values are requirement-satisfaction rates under this frozen protocol, not general ontology-accuracy or quality scores. The benchmark covers eight source records representing seven unique profiles; governance, maintainability, reasoning performance, usability, and scalability were not measured."
  },
  "legacy_h2kg_application_contract": {
    "schema_version": "h2kg-chameo-benchmark-contract/v1",
    "source_manifest_sha256": "C3A66E75FABDAF61C60949FFC7B0E08AAD324A1F77D6137BDE60FA20797001E6",
    "question_count": 50,
    "contract_sha256": "A1611EB141EB4E5B75BCDD98588996BC62DB71F9E28EDDFCD7ECAA470AFA94E5",
    "design_provenance": "The 50 questions predate the CHAMEO encoding and were inherited from the H2KG characterization application. They are source-grounded but not blinded, independently authored, or neutral with respect to H2KG's design.",
    "interpretation": "Historical asymmetric transfer diagnostic retained for reproducibility and excluded from the fair thirteen-requirement benchmark and its conclusion.",
    "questions": [
      {
        "query_id": "q1_tem_specimen_preparation",
        "plain_language_question": "Which specimen-preparation steps produced the TEM specimen associated with the reported particle-size result?",
        "query_family": "preparation_traceability",
        "variables": [
          "resultLabel",
          "specimenLabel",
          "preparationLabel",
          "preparedMaterialLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q2_tem_instrument_settings",
        "plain_language_question": "Which TEM instrument and acquisition settings were recorded, including values that were unconfirmed or not applicable?",
        "query_family": "measurement_parameter_identity_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "instrumentLabel",
          "parameterLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q3_tem_dataset_analysis",
        "plain_language_question": "Which image dataset, analysis process, and software produced the reported TEM result?",
        "query_family": "data_processing_and_provenance",
        "variables": [
          "inputDataLabel",
          "analysisLabel",
          "softwareLabel",
          "resultLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q4_tem_result_value",
        "plain_language_question": "What TEM property was reported, for which specimen, and with what source value and normalized unit?",
        "query_family": "result_property_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "resultLabel",
          "propertyLabel",
          "bearerLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q5_all_measurement_contexts",
        "plain_language_question": "What specimen, instrument, and raw dataset are linked to each characterization measurement?",
        "query_family": "measurement_context",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "measurementLabel",
          "specimenLabel",
          "instrumentLabel",
          "rawDatasetLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q6_all_result_records",
        "plain_language_question": "Which properties were reported across all cases, and what values, units, and specimen bearers were recorded?",
        "query_family": "result_property_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "resultLabel",
          "propertyLabel",
          "bearerLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q7_source_status_summary",
        "plain_language_question": "How many workbook fields in each case were reported, missing, not applicable, unspecified, unconfirmed, unresolved, or conflicting?",
        "query_family": "source_quality_control",
        "variables": [],
        "assessment_scope": "unscored_source_or_quality_control"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q8_all_measurement_parameters",
        "plain_language_question": "Which measurement settings were recorded across all cases, and which have normalized QUDT values and units?",
        "query_family": "measurement_parameter_identity_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "parameterLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q9_conservative_quantity_findings",
        "plain_language_question": "Which reported quantities were deliberately not normalized because their units, labels, axes, or meanings were incomplete or conflicting?",
        "query_family": "source_quality_control",
        "variables": [],
        "assessment_scope": "unscored_source_or_quality_control"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q10_source_provenance_coverage",
        "plain_language_question": "Does every eligible workbook field have a traceable semantic representation in each case graph?",
        "query_family": "source_quality_control",
        "variables": [],
        "assessment_scope": "unscored_source_or_quality_control"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q11_software_provenance",
        "plain_language_question": "Which software packages were linked to processing and analysis activities in each case?",
        "query_family": "data_processing_and_provenance",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "processLabel",
          "softwareLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q12_neutron_processing_chain",
        "plain_language_question": "Which ordered preprocessing transformations connect the neutron-tomography raw projections to processed data?",
        "query_family": "data_processing_and_provenance",
        "variables": [
          "processLabel",
          "inputDataLabel",
          "outputDataLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q13_tem_measurement_context",
        "plain_language_question": "What specimen, instrument, and raw dataset define the Transmission electron microscopy measurement?",
        "query_family": "measurement_context",
        "variables": [
          "measurementLabel",
          "specimenLabel",
          "instrumentLabel",
          "rawDatasetLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q14_sem_measurement_context",
        "plain_language_question": "What specimen, instrument, and raw dataset define the Scanning electron microscopy measurement?",
        "query_family": "measurement_context",
        "variables": [
          "measurementLabel",
          "specimenLabel",
          "instrumentLabel",
          "rawDatasetLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q15_afm_measurement_context",
        "plain_language_question": "What specimen, instrument, and raw dataset define the Atomic force microscopy measurement?",
        "query_family": "measurement_context",
        "variables": [
          "measurementLabel",
          "specimenLabel",
          "instrumentLabel",
          "rawDatasetLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q16_fib_sem_measurement_context",
        "plain_language_question": "What specimen, instrument, and raw dataset define the FIB-SEM tomography measurement?",
        "query_family": "measurement_context",
        "variables": [
          "measurementLabel",
          "specimenLabel",
          "instrumentLabel",
          "rawDatasetLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q17_ic_sem_measurement_context",
        "plain_language_question": "What specimen, instrument, and raw dataset define the Ion-cut scanning electron microscopy measurement?",
        "query_family": "measurement_context",
        "variables": [
          "measurementLabel",
          "specimenLabel",
          "instrumentLabel",
          "rawDatasetLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q18_neutron_tomography_measurement_context",
        "plain_language_question": "What specimen, instrument, and raw dataset define the Neutron tomography measurement?",
        "query_family": "measurement_context",
        "variables": [
          "measurementLabel",
          "specimenLabel",
          "instrumentLabel",
          "rawDatasetLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q19_synchrotron_radiography_measurement_context",
        "plain_language_question": "What specimen, instrument, and raw dataset define the Synchrotron X-ray radiography measurement?",
        "query_family": "measurement_context",
        "variables": [
          "measurementLabel",
          "specimenLabel",
          "instrumentLabel",
          "rawDatasetLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q20_synchrotron_tomography_measurement_context",
        "plain_language_question": "What specimen, instrument, and raw dataset define the Synchrotron X-ray tomography measurement?",
        "query_family": "measurement_context",
        "variables": [
          "measurementLabel",
          "specimenLabel",
          "instrumentLabel",
          "rawDatasetLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q21_tem_results",
        "plain_language_question": "Which results were reported for Transmission electron microscopy, and what values, units, and specimen bearers were recorded?",
        "query_family": "result_property_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "resultLabel",
          "propertyLabel",
          "bearerLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q22_sem_results",
        "plain_language_question": "Which results were reported for Scanning electron microscopy, and what values, units, and specimen bearers were recorded?",
        "query_family": "result_property_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "resultLabel",
          "propertyLabel",
          "bearerLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q23_afm_results",
        "plain_language_question": "Which results were reported for Atomic force microscopy, and what values, units, and specimen bearers were recorded?",
        "query_family": "result_property_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "resultLabel",
          "propertyLabel",
          "bearerLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q24_fib_sem_results",
        "plain_language_question": "Which results were reported for FIB-SEM tomography, and what values, units, and specimen bearers were recorded?",
        "query_family": "result_property_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "resultLabel",
          "propertyLabel",
          "bearerLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q25_ic_sem_results",
        "plain_language_question": "Which results were reported for Ion-cut scanning electron microscopy, and what values, units, and specimen bearers were recorded?",
        "query_family": "result_property_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "resultLabel",
          "propertyLabel",
          "bearerLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q26_neutron_tomography_results",
        "plain_language_question": "Which results were reported for Neutron tomography, and what values, units, and specimen bearers were recorded?",
        "query_family": "result_property_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "resultLabel",
          "propertyLabel",
          "bearerLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q27_synchrotron_radiography_results",
        "plain_language_question": "Which results were reported for Synchrotron X-ray radiography, and what values, units, and specimen bearers were recorded?",
        "query_family": "result_property_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "resultLabel",
          "propertyLabel",
          "bearerLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q28_synchrotron_tomography_results",
        "plain_language_question": "Which results were reported for Synchrotron X-ray tomography, and what values, units, and specimen bearers were recorded?",
        "query_family": "result_property_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "resultLabel",
          "propertyLabel",
          "bearerLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q29_tem_source_status",
        "plain_language_question": "How many Transmission electron microscopy source fields were reported, missing, not applicable, unspecified, unconfirmed, unresolved, or conflicting?",
        "query_family": "source_quality_control",
        "variables": [],
        "assessment_scope": "unscored_source_or_quality_control"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q30_sem_source_status",
        "plain_language_question": "How many Scanning electron microscopy source fields were reported, missing, not applicable, unspecified, unconfirmed, unresolved, or conflicting?",
        "query_family": "source_quality_control",
        "variables": [],
        "assessment_scope": "unscored_source_or_quality_control"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q31_afm_source_status",
        "plain_language_question": "How many Atomic force microscopy source fields were reported, missing, not applicable, unspecified, unconfirmed, unresolved, or conflicting?",
        "query_family": "source_quality_control",
        "variables": [],
        "assessment_scope": "unscored_source_or_quality_control"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q32_fib_sem_source_status",
        "plain_language_question": "How many FIB-SEM tomography source fields were reported, missing, not applicable, unspecified, unconfirmed, unresolved, or conflicting?",
        "query_family": "source_quality_control",
        "variables": [],
        "assessment_scope": "unscored_source_or_quality_control"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q33_ic_sem_source_status",
        "plain_language_question": "How many Ion-cut scanning electron microscopy source fields were reported, missing, not applicable, unspecified, unconfirmed, unresolved, or conflicting?",
        "query_family": "source_quality_control",
        "variables": [],
        "assessment_scope": "unscored_source_or_quality_control"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q34_neutron_tomography_source_status",
        "plain_language_question": "How many Neutron tomography source fields were reported, missing, not applicable, unspecified, unconfirmed, unresolved, or conflicting?",
        "query_family": "source_quality_control",
        "variables": [],
        "assessment_scope": "unscored_source_or_quality_control"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q35_synchrotron_radiography_source_status",
        "plain_language_question": "How many Synchrotron X-ray radiography source fields were reported, missing, not applicable, unspecified, unconfirmed, unresolved, or conflicting?",
        "query_family": "source_quality_control",
        "variables": [],
        "assessment_scope": "unscored_source_or_quality_control"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q36_synchrotron_tomography_source_status",
        "plain_language_question": "How many Synchrotron X-ray tomography source fields were reported, missing, not applicable, unspecified, unconfirmed, unresolved, or conflicting?",
        "query_family": "source_quality_control",
        "variables": [],
        "assessment_scope": "unscored_source_or_quality_control"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q37_tem_measurement_settings",
        "plain_language_question": "Which acquisition settings were recorded for Transmission electron microscopy, and which have normalized values and units?",
        "query_family": "measurement_parameter_identity_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "parameterLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q38_sem_measurement_settings",
        "plain_language_question": "Which acquisition settings were recorded for Scanning electron microscopy, and which have normalized values and units?",
        "query_family": "measurement_parameter_identity_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "parameterLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q39_afm_measurement_settings",
        "plain_language_question": "Which acquisition settings were recorded for Atomic force microscopy, and which have normalized values and units?",
        "query_family": "measurement_parameter_identity_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "parameterLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q40_fib_sem_measurement_settings",
        "plain_language_question": "Which acquisition settings were recorded for FIB-SEM tomography, and which have normalized values and units?",
        "query_family": "measurement_parameter_identity_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "parameterLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q41_ic_sem_measurement_settings",
        "plain_language_question": "Which acquisition settings were recorded for Ion-cut scanning electron microscopy, and which have normalized values and units?",
        "query_family": "measurement_parameter_identity_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "parameterLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q42_neutron_tomography_measurement_settings",
        "plain_language_question": "Which acquisition settings were recorded for Neutron tomography, and which have normalized values and units?",
        "query_family": "measurement_parameter_identity_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "parameterLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q43_synchrotron_radiography_measurement_settings",
        "plain_language_question": "Which acquisition settings were recorded for Synchrotron X-ray radiography, and which have normalized values and units?",
        "query_family": "measurement_parameter_identity_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "parameterLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q44_synchrotron_tomography_measurement_settings",
        "plain_language_question": "Which acquisition settings were recorded for Synchrotron X-ray tomography, and which have normalized values and units?",
        "query_family": "measurement_parameter_identity_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "parameterLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q45_case_measurement_result_counts",
        "plain_language_question": "How many measurement occurrences and result records are represented for each characterization case?",
        "query_family": "occurrence_accounting",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "measurementCount",
          "resultCount"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q46_normalized_result_quantities",
        "plain_language_question": "Which reported scientific results have both a defensible numeric value and an explicit QUDT unit?",
        "query_family": "result_property_and_value",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "propertyLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q47_qualified_source_fields",
        "plain_language_question": "Which workbook fields are not simply reported values, and why are they marked missing, inapplicable, unspecified, unconfirmed, unresolved, or conflicting?",
        "query_family": "source_quality_control",
        "variables": [],
        "assessment_scope": "unscored_source_or_quality_control"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q48_qualified_measurement_settings",
        "plain_language_question": "Which acquisition settings are missing, not applicable, unspecified, unconfirmed, unresolved, or conflicting rather than fully reported?",
        "query_family": "source_quality_control",
        "variables": [],
        "assessment_scope": "unscored_source_or_quality_control"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q49_analysis_provenance_across_cases",
        "plain_language_question": "Which input datasets, analysis processes, and software are linked to each reported result across all cases?",
        "query_family": "data_processing_and_provenance",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "analysisLabel",
          "inputDataLabel",
          "resultLabel",
          "softwareLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      },
      {
        "query_id": "q50_preprocessing_transformations",
        "plain_language_question": "Which preprocessing activities transformed which input datasets into which output datasets across the eight cases?",
        "query_family": "data_processing_and_provenance",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "processLabel",
          "inputDataLabel",
          "outputDataLabel"
        ],
        "assessment_scope": "strict_ontology_semantics"
      }
    ]
  },
  "legacy_transfer_test": {
    "question_count": 50,
    "scored_query_count": 37,
    "unscored_control_count": 13,
    "expected_row_count": 460,
    "h2kg": {
      "queries_passed": 37,
      "queries_partial_or_failed": 0,
      "matched_rows": 460,
      "observed_rows": 460,
      "micro_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "micro_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "micro_f1_percent": 100.0
    },
    "chameo": {
      "queries_passed": 25,
      "queries_partial_or_failed": 12,
      "matched_rows": 241,
      "observed_rows": 458,
      "micro_precision_percent": 52.62,
      "micro_recall_percent": 52.39,
      "micro_f1_percent": 52.51
    },
    "by_query_family": {
      "data_processing_and_provenance": {
        "query_count": 5,
        "expected_rows": 92,
        "h2kg": {
          "queries_passed": 5,
          "matched_rows": 92,
          "observed_rows": 92,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "queries_passed": 5,
          "matched_rows": 92,
          "observed_rows": 92,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      },
      "measurement_context": {
        "query_count": 9,
        "expected_rows": 16,
        "h2kg": {
          "queries_passed": 9,
          "matched_rows": 16,
          "observed_rows": 16,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "queries_passed": 9,
          "matched_rows": 16,
          "observed_rows": 16,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      },
      "measurement_parameter_identity_and_value": {
        "query_count": 10,
        "expected_rows": 276,
        "h2kg": {
          "queries_passed": 10,
          "matched_rows": 276,
          "observed_rows": 276,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "queries_passed": 0,
          "matched_rows": 57,
          "observed_rows": 270,
          "precision_percent": 21.11,
          "recall_percent": 20.65
        }
      },
      "occurrence_accounting": {
        "query_count": 1,
        "expected_rows": 8,
        "h2kg": {
          "queries_passed": 1,
          "matched_rows": 8,
          "observed_rows": 8,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "queries_passed": 1,
          "matched_rows": 8,
          "observed_rows": 8,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      },
      "preparation_traceability": {
        "query_count": 1,
        "expected_rows": 6,
        "h2kg": {
          "queries_passed": 1,
          "matched_rows": 6,
          "observed_rows": 6,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "queries_passed": 1,
          "matched_rows": 6,
          "observed_rows": 6,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      },
      "result_property_and_value": {
        "query_count": 11,
        "expected_rows": 62,
        "h2kg": {
          "queries_passed": 11,
          "matched_rows": 62,
          "observed_rows": 62,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "queries_passed": 9,
          "matched_rows": 62,
          "observed_rows": 66,
          "precision_percent": 93.94,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      }
    },
    "semantic_contract_diagnostics": [
      {
        "contract_id": "measurement_context",
        "source_query_id": "q5_all_measurement_contexts",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "measurementLabel",
          "specimenLabel",
          "instrumentLabel",
          "rawDatasetLabel"
        ],
        "expected_rows": 8,
        "h2kg": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 8,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 8,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      },
      {
        "contract_id": "measurement_parameter_identity",
        "source_query_id": "q8_all_measurement_parameters",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "parameterLabel"
        ],
        "expected_rows": 134,
        "h2kg": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 131,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 131,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      },
      {
        "contract_id": "normalized_measurement_parameter_value",
        "source_query_id": "q8_all_measurement_parameters",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "parameterLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "expected_rows": 107,
        "h2kg": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 107,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "status": "fail",
          "matched_rows": 0,
          "missing_rows": 107,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 0.0,
          "recall_percent": 0.0
        }
      },
      {
        "contract_id": "result_property_bearer_association",
        "source_query_id": "q6_all_result_records",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "resultLabel",
          "propertyLabel",
          "bearerLabel"
        ],
        "expected_rows": 24,
        "h2kg": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 24,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "status": "fail",
          "matched_rows": 24,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 2,
          "precision_percent": 92.31,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      },
      {
        "contract_id": "normalized_result_value",
        "source_query_id": "q46_normalized_result_quantities",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "propertyLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "expected_rows": 13,
        "h2kg": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 13,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 13,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      }
    ]
  },
  "benchmark_policy": {
    "comparison_type": "balanced_ontology_neutral_characterization_record_benchmark",
    "abox_construction": "independent_direct_mapping_from_the_same_sanitized_manifest",
    "cross_graph_translation": false,
    "ontology_tbox_modification": false,
    "local_semantic_extensions_allowed": false,
    "source_layer_allowed_in_scored_queries": false,
    "ground_truth_source": "sanitized workbook manifest",
    "ontology_specific_sparql": true,
    "same_variables_and_expected_rows": true,
    "declared_imports_allowed_and_reported_separately": true,
    "shared_standards_not_credited_as_ontology_specific": true,
    "requirement_selection": "Thirteen requirements derived from the source characterization lifecycle and named by scientific function; every requirement is scored once over all eight source records, representing seven unique profiles, and none is selected by ontology origin.",
    "comparison_method": "Deduplicated result-set equality after numeric lexical normalization for query-based requirements; explicit native-pattern assessment for unsupported-query cases; native vocabulary coverage for the selected profiles.",
    "quantity_interpretation": "Numeric parsing and recognized-unit mapping are distinct from rule-based scientific property/unit compatibility screening.",
    "conclusion_rule": "The complementarity statement is emitted only when every explicit machine-checkable decision rule passes.",
    "legacy_question_set_status": "Retained as a historical asymmetric transfer-test diagnostic and excluded from the primary conclusion."
  },
  "source_lock": {
    "schema_version": "chameo-emmo-source-lock/v2",
    "generated_at": "2026-10-26T12:01:32+00:00",
    "network_required_for_build": false,
    "chameo_version": "1.0.3",
    "chameo_commit": "01520fd7bc6f76ec5ff32a051533326a198c499c",
    "emmo_version": "1.0.3",
    "emmo_commit": "b85a0803c47819fc4b53b9c9fd6c61878f714c5b",
    "direct_import_count": 12,
    "transitive_import_count": 13,
    "resolved_import_count": 25,
    "complete_import_closure": true,
    "lock_fingerprint": "B12265A4950CDE1E4258572282FFEDAE34E85DDCD03944917EF9EA055FF312FF"
  },
  "graph_statistics": {
    "h2kg": {
      "named_graph_count": 9,
      "triple_count": 3722,
      "semantic_entity_count": 899,
      "turtle_jsonld_isomorphic": true
    },
    "chameo": {
      "named_graph_count": 9,
      "triple_count": 2483,
      "semantic_entity_count": 709,
      "turtle_jsonld_isomorphic": true
    }
  },
  "mapping_coverage": {
    "eligible_source_fields": 1635,
    "h2kg_mapping_assertions": 1659,
    "h2kg_unique_source_fields": 1635,
    "h2kg_additional_assertions_for_multimapped_fields": 24,
    "chameo_mapping_rows": 1635,
    "chameo_strict_assertion_status_counts": {
      "asserted_without_local_bridge": 1030,
      "identity_asserted_value_link_not_asserted": 134,
      "source_evidence_only_excluded_from_scoring": 471
    },
    "chameo_primary_tier_counts": {
      "native_generic": 1118,
      "native_specific": 33,
      "shared_standard": 13,
      "source_only": 471
    }
  },
  "query_benchmark": {
    "question_count": 50,
    "scored_query_count": 37,
    "unscored_control_count": 13,
    "expected_row_count": 460,
    "h2kg": {
      "queries_passed": 37,
      "queries_partial_or_failed": 0,
      "matched_rows": 460,
      "observed_rows": 460,
      "micro_precision_percent": 100.0,
      "micro_recall_percent": 100.0,
      "micro_f1_percent": 100.0
    },
    "chameo": {
      "queries_passed": 25,
      "queries_partial_or_failed": 12,
      "matched_rows": 241,
      "observed_rows": 458,
      "micro_precision_percent": 52.62,
      "micro_recall_percent": 52.39,
      "micro_f1_percent": 52.51
    },
    "by_query_family": {
      "data_processing_and_provenance": {
        "query_count": 5,
        "expected_rows": 92,
        "h2kg": {
          "queries_passed": 5,
          "matched_rows": 92,
          "observed_rows": 92,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "queries_passed": 5,
          "matched_rows": 92,
          "observed_rows": 92,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      },
      "measurement_context": {
        "query_count": 9,
        "expected_rows": 16,
        "h2kg": {
          "queries_passed": 9,
          "matched_rows": 16,
          "observed_rows": 16,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "queries_passed": 9,
          "matched_rows": 16,
          "observed_rows": 16,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      },
      "measurement_parameter_identity_and_value": {
        "query_count": 10,
        "expected_rows": 276,
        "h2kg": {
          "queries_passed": 10,
          "matched_rows": 276,
          "observed_rows": 276,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "queries_passed": 0,
          "matched_rows": 57,
          "observed_rows": 270,
          "precision_percent": 21.11,
          "recall_percent": 20.65
        }
      },
      "occurrence_accounting": {
        "query_count": 1,
        "expected_rows": 8,
        "h2kg": {
          "queries_passed": 1,
          "matched_rows": 8,
          "observed_rows": 8,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "queries_passed": 1,
          "matched_rows": 8,
          "observed_rows": 8,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      },
      "preparation_traceability": {
        "query_count": 1,
        "expected_rows": 6,
        "h2kg": {
          "queries_passed": 1,
          "matched_rows": 6,
          "observed_rows": 6,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "queries_passed": 1,
          "matched_rows": 6,
          "observed_rows": 6,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      },
      "result_property_and_value": {
        "query_count": 11,
        "expected_rows": 62,
        "h2kg": {
          "queries_passed": 11,
          "matched_rows": 62,
          "observed_rows": 62,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "queries_passed": 9,
          "matched_rows": 62,
          "observed_rows": 66,
          "precision_percent": 93.94,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      }
    },
    "semantic_contract_diagnostics": [
      {
        "contract_id": "measurement_context",
        "source_query_id": "q5_all_measurement_contexts",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "measurementLabel",
          "specimenLabel",
          "instrumentLabel",
          "rawDatasetLabel"
        ],
        "expected_rows": 8,
        "h2kg": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 8,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 8,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      },
      {
        "contract_id": "measurement_parameter_identity",
        "source_query_id": "q8_all_measurement_parameters",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "parameterLabel"
        ],
        "expected_rows": 134,
        "h2kg": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 131,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 131,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      },
      {
        "contract_id": "normalized_measurement_parameter_value",
        "source_query_id": "q8_all_measurement_parameters",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "parameterLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "expected_rows": 107,
        "h2kg": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 107,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "status": "fail",
          "matched_rows": 0,
          "missing_rows": 107,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 0.0,
          "recall_percent": 0.0
        }
      },
      {
        "contract_id": "result_property_bearer_association",
        "source_query_id": "q6_all_result_records",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "resultLabel",
          "propertyLabel",
          "bearerLabel"
        ],
        "expected_rows": 24,
        "h2kg": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 24,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "status": "fail",
          "matched_rows": 24,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 2,
          "precision_percent": 92.31,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      },
      {
        "contract_id": "normalized_result_value",
        "source_query_id": "q46_normalized_result_quantities",
        "variables": [
          "caseKey",
          "propertyLabel",
          "value",
          "unit"
        ],
        "expected_rows": 13,
        "h2kg": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 13,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        },
        "chameo": {
          "status": "pass",
          "matched_rows": 13,
          "missing_rows": 0,
          "unexpected_rows": 0,
          "precision_percent": 100.0,
          "recall_percent": 100.0
        }
      }
    ]
  },
  "capability_matrix": [
    {
      "capability": "Explicit workflow and task grouping",
      "h2kg": "generic_direct_native",
      "chameo": "specialized_direct_native",
      "h2kg_evidence": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#Process;https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#hasPart",
      "chameo_evidence": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#CharacterisationWorkflow;https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#hasCharacterisationTask;https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#CharacterisationTask"
    },
    {
      "capability": "Measurement subject",
      "h2kg": "direct_native",
      "chameo": "direct_native",
      "h2kg_evidence": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#hasMeasurementSubject",
      "chameo_evidence": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#hasMeasurementSample"
    },
    {
      "capability": "Instrument used",
      "h2kg": "direct_native",
      "chameo": "direct_native",
      "h2kg_evidence": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#usesInstrument",
      "chameo_evidence": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#hasCharacterisationMeasurementInstrument"
    },
    {
      "capability": "Technique descriptor and occurrence",
      "h2kg": "occurrence_class_without_separate_descriptor",
      "chameo": "direct_via_declared_import",
      "h2kg_evidence": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#Measurement",
      "chameo_evidence": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#CharacterisationTechnique;https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_f702bad4_fc77_41f0_a26d_79f6444fd4f3;https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#CharacterisationMeasurementProcess"
    },
    {
      "capability": "Measurement parameter identity",
      "h2kg": "direct_native",
      "chameo": "direct_native",
      "h2kg_evidence": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#hasParameter",
      "chameo_evidence": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#hasMeasurementParameter"
    },
    {
      "capability": "Parameter-to-characteristic/value",
      "h2kg": "direct_native_plus_shared_value",
      "chameo": "native_pattern_not_identified_under_mapping_rules",
      "h2kg_evidence": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#ofProperty;https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#hasQuantityValue",
      "chameo_evidence": "Under the benchmark's permitted native encoding, no declared ancestry-compatible relation was identified from MeasurementParameter to a distinct Property or Quantity. This does not establish that all alternative CHAMEO/EMMO encodings are prohibited."
    },
    {
      "capability": "Raw and processed datasets",
      "h2kg": "direct_native",
      "chameo": "direct_native",
      "h2kg_evidence": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#hasInputData;https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#hasOutputData",
      "chameo_evidence": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#hasCharacterisationInput;https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#hasCharacterisationOutput"
    },
    {
      "capability": "Data processing and analysis",
      "h2kg": "direct_native",
      "chameo": "direct_native",
      "h2kg_evidence": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#DataProcessing;https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#Process",
      "chameo_evidence": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#DataPreparation;https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#DataAnalysis"
    },
    {
      "capability": "Software used",
      "h2kg": "direct_native",
      "chameo": "direct_native",
      "h2kg_evidence": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#usesSoftware",
      "chameo_evidence": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#hasCharacterisationSoftware"
    },
    {
      "capability": "Sample-to-property bearer",
      "h2kg": "direct_native",
      "chameo": "direct_native",
      "h2kg_evidence": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#isCharacteristicOf",
      "chameo_evidence": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#hasCharacterisationProperty"
    },
    {
      "capability": "Result-to-property association",
      "h2kg": "direct_native_result_level",
      "chameo": "declared_import_application_pattern",
      "h2kg_evidence": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#ofProperty",
      "chameo_evidence": "The source analysis is typed as https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#DataAnalysis and https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_10a5fd39_06aa_4648_9e70_f962a9cb2069; https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#hasCharacterisationOutput identifies result data and https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_802b7639_9498_4b47_ad45_1a087fe8fb85 identifies the determined property. CHAMEO does not entail that additional EMMO type from DataAnalysis, and the process-level pattern is ambiguous when one analysis has multiple results and properties."
    },
    {
      "capability": "Result generation provenance",
      "h2kg": "direct_shared_standard",
      "chameo": "direct_shared_standard",
      "h2kg_evidence": "http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#wasGeneratedBy",
      "chameo_evidence": "http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#wasGeneratedBy"
    },
    {
      "capability": "Normalized value and unit",
      "h2kg": "direct_native_plus_shared_standard",
      "chameo": "direct_import_plus_shared_standard_for_property",
      "h2kg_evidence": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#hasQuantityValue;http://qudt.org/schema/qudt/unit",
      "chameo_evidence": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_88b84515_a0df_47bb_8166_c7c8b893c1d8;http://qudt.org/schema/qudt/unit"
    },
    {
      "capability": "Missingness and source-cell status",
      "h2kg": "source_layer_only",
      "chameo": "source_layer_only",
      "h2kg_evidence": "Not counted in strict ontology benchmark",
      "chameo_evidence": "Not counted in strict ontology benchmark"
    }
  ],
  "capability_coverage": {
    "h2kg": {
      "direct_native": 7,
      "direct_native_plus_shared_standard": 1,
      "direct_native_plus_shared_value": 1,
      "direct_native_result_level": 1,
      "direct_shared_standard": 1,
      "generic_direct_native": 1,
      "occurrence_class_without_separate_descriptor": 1,
      "source_layer_only": 1
    },
    "chameo": {
      "declared_import_application_pattern": 1,
      "direct_import_plus_shared_standard_for_property": 1,
      "direct_native": 7,
      "direct_shared_standard": 1,
      "direct_via_declared_import": 1,
      "native_pattern_not_identified_under_mapping_rules": 1,
      "source_layer_only": 1,
      "specialized_direct_native": 1
    }
  },
  "ontology_evidence_audit": {
    "schema_version": "h2kg-chameo-ontology-evidence-audit/v1",
    "source_lock_fingerprint": "B12265A4950CDE1E4258572282FFEDAE34E85DDCD03944917EF9EA055FF312FF",
    "complete_import_closure": true,
    "direct_import_count": 12,
    "transitive_import_count": 13,
    "resolved_import_count": 25,
    "tbox_triple_count": 16668,
    "measurement_parameter": {
      "class_iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#MeasurementParameter",
      "ancestor_path": [
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_057e7d57_aff0_49de_911a_8861d85cef40",
          "label": "Symbolic"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_1e877c70_3b01_45a8_a8f6_8ce4f6a24660",
          "label": "Contrast"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_1eed0732_e3f1_4b2c_a9c4_b4e75eeb5895",
          "label": "Variable"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_3e7add3d_e6ed_489a_a796_8e31fef9b490",
          "label": "Data"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_49267eba_5548_4163_8f36_518d65b583f9",
          "label": "Perspective"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_53ed8611_2cd7_4286_9ef0_36572117b963",
          "label": "Fusion"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_54ee6b5e_5261_44a8_86eb_5717e7fdb9d0",
          "label": "Mathematical"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_802d3e92_8770_4f98_a289_ccaaab7fdddf",
          "label": "EMMO"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_9e029526_79a2_47a8_a151_dd0545db471b",
          "label": "NumericalVariable"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_be8592a7_68d1_4a06_ad23_82f2b56ef926",
          "label": "DiscreteData"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_c5ddfdba_c074_4aa4_ad6b_1ac4942d300d",
          "label": "CausalStructure"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_c66ad523_3937_485e_91bb_ad488ddb373f",
          "label": "DataByDiscretness"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_d1d436e7_72fc_49cd_863b_7bfb4ba5276a",
          "label": "Parameter"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_d8d2144e_5c8d_455d_a643_5caf4d8d9df8",
          "label": "Language"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_eb3a768e_d53e_4be9_a23b_0714833c36de",
          "label": "Item"
        },
        {
          "iri": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#MeasurementParameter",
          "label": "MeasurementParameter"
        }
      ],
      "is_emmo_mathematical_parameter": true,
      "is_emmo_quantity": false,
      "is_emmo_referent": false,
      "emmo_has_property_domain": [
        "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_6f5af708_f825_4feb_a0d1_a8d813d3022b"
      ],
      "emmo_has_property_domain_applicable": false,
      "emmo_has_quantity_value_domain": [
        "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_0650c031_42b6_4f0a_b62d_d88f071da6bf"
      ],
      "emmo_has_quantity_value_domain_applicable": false,
      "declared_applicable_property_relations": [],
      "declared_applicable_value_relations": [],
      "finding": "Within the benchmark's inspected native pattern and mapping rules, the pinned CHAMEO/EMMO closure supplies parameter identity but no declared ancestry-compatible relation from MeasurementParameter to a distinct valued scientific characteristic. This is not a general impossibility finding."
    },
    "result_semantics": {
      "data_analysis_is_declared_emmo_determination": false,
      "chameo_has_sample_property_relation": true,
      "emmo_has_determined_property_relation": true,
      "finding": "CHAMEO supplies sample-to-property semantics. The scored result association uses an explicit EMMO Determination application pattern; CHAMEO DataAnalysis does not entail that type and the process-level pattern is ambiguous for multi-result analyses."
    },
    "workflow_and_technique": {
      "chameo_workflow_class_present": true,
      "chameo_task_relation_present": true,
      "chameo_technique_class_present": true,
      "emmo_description_relation_present": true
    },
    "scored_abox_assertions": {
      "h2kg_measurement_to_parameter": 218,
      "h2kg_parameter_to_property": 242,
      "h2kg_property_to_quantity_value": 120,
      "chameo_measurement_to_parameter": 218,
      "chameo_parameter_to_distinct_property": 0,
      "h2kg_workflow_parts": 127,
      "chameo_workflow_tasks": 127,
      "chameo_technique_to_occurrence": 135
    },
    "method_specificity": [
      {
        "case": "tem",
        "method": "Transmission electron microscopy",
        "mapping_basis": "Source method label and workflow evidence.",
        "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#TransmissionElectronMicroscopyImaging",
        "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
        "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#TransmissionElectronMicroscopy",
        "chameo_specificity": "specific_native",
        "chameo_terms_present": true
      },
      {
        "case": "sem",
        "method": "Scanning electron microscopy",
        "mapping_basis": "Source method label and workflow evidence.",
        "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#ScanningElectronMicroscopyImaging",
        "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
        "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#ScanningElectronMicroscopy",
        "chameo_specificity": "specific_native",
        "chameo_terms_present": true
      },
      {
        "case": "afm",
        "method": "Atomic force microscopy",
        "mapping_basis": "Source method label and workflow evidence.",
        "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#AtomicForceMicroscopyMeasurement",
        "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
        "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#AtomicForceMicroscopy",
        "chameo_specificity": "specific_native",
        "chameo_terms_present": true
      },
      {
        "case": "fib_sem",
        "method": "FIB-SEM tomography",
        "mapping_basis": "Source method label and workflow evidence.",
        "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#FIBSEMTomographyMeasurement",
        "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
        "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#Tomography;https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#ScanningElectronMicroscopy",
        "chameo_specificity": "composite_broader_native",
        "chameo_terms_present": true
      },
      {
        "case": "ic_sem",
        "method": "Ion-cut scanning electron microscopy",
        "mapping_basis": "Source method label and workflow evidence.",
        "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#ICSEMImagingMeasurement",
        "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
        "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#ScanningElectronMicroscopy",
        "chameo_specificity": "broader_native",
        "chameo_terms_present": true
      },
      {
        "case": "neutron_tomography",
        "method": "Neutron tomography",
        "mapping_basis": "Source method label and workflow evidence.",
        "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#NeutronTomographyMeasurement",
        "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
        "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#Tomography",
        "chameo_specificity": "broader_native",
        "chameo_terms_present": true
      },
      {
        "case": "synchrotron_radiography",
        "method": "Synchrotron X-ray radiography",
        "mapping_basis": "The sheet key says radiography, but the curated MeasurementMethod and 3D reconstruction chain identify tomography.",
        "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#XRayComputedTomographyMeasurement",
        "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
        "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#Tomography",
        "chameo_specificity": "broader_native",
        "chameo_terms_present": true
      },
      {
        "case": "synchrotron_tomography",
        "method": "Synchrotron X-ray tomography",
        "mapping_basis": "Source method label and workflow evidence.",
        "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#XRayComputedTomographyMeasurement",
        "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
        "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#Tomography",
        "chameo_specificity": "broader_native",
        "chameo_terms_present": true
      }
    ]
  },
  "method_specificity": [
    {
      "case": "tem",
      "method": "Transmission electron microscopy",
      "mapping_basis": "Source method label and workflow evidence.",
      "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#TransmissionElectronMicroscopyImaging",
      "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
      "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#TransmissionElectronMicroscopy",
      "chameo_specificity": "specific_native"
    },
    {
      "case": "sem",
      "method": "Scanning electron microscopy",
      "mapping_basis": "Source method label and workflow evidence.",
      "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#ScanningElectronMicroscopyImaging",
      "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
      "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#ScanningElectronMicroscopy",
      "chameo_specificity": "specific_native"
    },
    {
      "case": "afm",
      "method": "Atomic force microscopy",
      "mapping_basis": "Source method label and workflow evidence.",
      "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#AtomicForceMicroscopyMeasurement",
      "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
      "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#AtomicForceMicroscopy",
      "chameo_specificity": "specific_native"
    },
    {
      "case": "fib_sem",
      "method": "FIB-SEM tomography",
      "mapping_basis": "Source method label and workflow evidence.",
      "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#FIBSEMTomographyMeasurement",
      "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
      "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#Tomography;https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#ScanningElectronMicroscopy",
      "chameo_specificity": "composite_broader_native"
    },
    {
      "case": "ic_sem",
      "method": "Ion-cut scanning electron microscopy",
      "mapping_basis": "Source method label and workflow evidence.",
      "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#ICSEMImagingMeasurement",
      "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
      "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#ScanningElectronMicroscopy",
      "chameo_specificity": "broader_native"
    },
    {
      "case": "neutron_tomography",
      "method": "Neutron tomography",
      "mapping_basis": "Source method label and workflow evidence.",
      "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#NeutronTomographyMeasurement",
      "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
      "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#Tomography",
      "chameo_specificity": "broader_native"
    },
    {
      "case": "synchrotron_radiography",
      "method": "Synchrotron X-ray radiography",
      "mapping_basis": "The sheet key says radiography, but the curated MeasurementMethod and 3D reconstruction chain identify tomography.",
      "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#XRayComputedTomographyMeasurement",
      "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
      "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#Tomography",
      "chameo_specificity": "broader_native"
    },
    {
      "case": "synchrotron_tomography",
      "method": "Synchrotron X-ray tomography",
      "mapping_basis": "Source method label and workflow evidence.",
      "h2kg_term": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#XRayComputedTomographyMeasurement",
      "h2kg_specificity": "specific_native",
      "chameo_term": "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#Tomography",
      "chameo_specificity": "broader_native"
    }
  ],
  "mapping_policy_constraints": [
    {
      "requirement": "Measurement parameter identity",
      "h2kg": "no additional semantic relation",
      "chameo": "no additional semantic relation",
      "evidence": "https://w3id.org/h2kg/hydrogen-ontology#hasParameter;https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#hasMeasurementParameter"
    },
    {
      "requirement": "Measurement parameter characteristic, value, and unit",
      "h2kg": "supported by H2KG relation plus shared QUDT",
      "chameo": "not supported by the permitted native encoding",
      "evidence": "Under the frozen mapping rules, no declared ancestry-compatible relation was identified from CHAMEO MeasurementParameter to a distinct Property or Quantity. This is a bounded policy finding, not an impossibility proof."
    },
    {
      "requirement": "Analysis-level determined property",
      "h2kg": "available through result-level ofProperty",
      "chameo": "no new predicate; explicit application typing and assertion from the declared EMMO import",
      "evidence": "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_10a5fd39_06aa_4648_9e70_f962a9cb2069;https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_802b7639_9498_4b47_ad45_1a087fe8fb85. CHAMEO DataAnalysis is not formally a subclass of EMMO Determination in the pinned graph."
    },
    {
      "requirement": "Unambiguous result-data to property association",
      "h2kg": "supported by a direct result-level relation",
      "chameo": "the tested process-level encoding is ambiguous for one multi-result analysis",
      "evidence": "The tested process-level EMMO encoding yields two additional result/property combinations for the IC-SEM multi-output analysis; this does not characterize every permissible CHAMEO encoding."
    },
    {
      "requirement": "Source-cell status and missingness",
      "h2kg": "neutral source layer required",
      "chameo": "neutral source layer required",
      "evidence": "Excluded from ontology-specific scoring for both graphs."
    }
  ],
  "shacl": {
    "chameo": {
      "conforms": true,
      "negative_tests": [
        {
          "requirement": "measurement_subject",
          "removed_triples": [
            [
              "https://example.org/aimworks/chameo-characterization/afm/measurement/atomic-force-microscopy-652d6f492a",
              "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#hasMeasurementSample",
              "https://example.org/aimworks/chameo-characterization/afm/sample/sample-a0d27d1adc"
            ]
          ],
          "conforms": false
        },
        {
          "requirement": "measurement_instrument",
          "removed_triples": [
            [
              "https://example.org/aimworks/chameo-characterization/afm/measurement/atomic-force-microscopy-652d6f492a",
              "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#hasCharacterisationMeasurementInstrument",
              "https://example.org/aimworks/chameo-characterization/afm/instrument/atomic-force-microscopy-2e89e780a7"
            ]
          ],
          "conforms": false
        },
        {
          "requirement": "measurement_output",
          "removed_triples": [
            [
              "https://example.org/aimworks/chameo-characterization/afm/measurement/atomic-force-microscopy-652d6f492a",
              "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#hasCharacterisationOutput",
              "https://example.org/aimworks/chameo-characterization/afm/data/rawdata-dc9e836707"
            ]
          ],
          "conforms": false
        },
        {
          "requirement": "analysis_input",
          "removed_triples": [
            [
              "https://example.org/aimworks/chameo-characterization/afm/anal-process/manual-particle-measurement-4128ca07e7",
              "https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo#hasCharacterisationInput",
              "https://example.org/aimworks/chameo-characterization/afm/data/post-processed-image-3efdbfdaba"
            ]
          ],
          "conforms": false
        },
        {
          "requirement": "analysis_determined_property",
          "removed_triples": [
            [
              "https://example.org/aimworks/chameo-characterization/afm/anal-process/manual-particle-measurement-4128ca07e7",
              "https://w3id.org/emmo#EMMO_802b7639_9498_4b47_ad45_1a087fe8fb85",
              "https://example.org/aimworks/chameo-characterization/afm/characterisation-property/average-size-fdbfa59eb2"
            ]
          ],
          "conforms": false
        }
      ]
    },
    "comparison_limit": "Both graphs are tested against the same source-derived requirements. The complete CHAMEO/EMMO transitive import closure is available to CHAMEO. Under the benchmark's permitted native encoding, no ancestry-compatible parameter-record-to-valued-characteristic path was identified; this is not a proof that every alternative CHAMEO/EMMO encoding is impossible. The analysis-to-property constraint uses an explicit imported EMMO application pattern and is not described as a CHAMEO entailment."
  },
  "excluded_preliminary_method": {
    "publication_status": "not_a_benchmark",
    "reason": "An earlier adapter-assisted run used a neutral source layer and local bridge relations. Its scores are excluded rather than reported as ontology capability."
  },
  "interpretation": {
    "complementarity": "For the selected characterization profiles, the benchmark supports a scoped complementarity conclusion: CHAMEO provides explicit characterization-methodology structures, while H₂KG provides greater native class coverage at the predefined profile granularity together with direct valued-parameter and individually provenance-linked result patterns.",
    "conclusion_supported": true,
    "limits": "The 12/13 and 10/13 values are requirement-satisfaction rates under this frozen protocol, not general ontology-accuracy or quality scores. The benchmark covers eight source records representing seven unique profiles; governance, maintainability, reasoning performance, usability, and scalability were not measured."
  }
}